bnt attorneys for CEE close.straight.forward

Guiding your
business in CEE.

С нас Вашият бизнес има предимството на родното място

В Центална и Източна Европа ние сме у дома. Както никой друг.

С нашите презицни консултации Вие постигате своите цели

Нашите специалисти превръщат сложните задачи в ефективни решения.

Заедно напред

Нашите съдружници мислят предприемачески и работят лично по Вашите проекти. За да имате успех.

 
 

The Supreme Court of the Czech Republic has ruled that a person occupying a non-rental property without an agreement with the owner is not obliged to make payments to the owner on the legal ground of unjust enrichment.

According to a general civil-law principle, nobody must enrich themselves groundlessly at the expense of someone else. The concept of unjust enrichment also covers the pecuniary advantage derived by someone who unlawfully uses third-party property – i.e., who uses such property in the absence of a valid contract or other legal title. Whoever enriches themselves in this manner at the expense of the owner must surrender the advantage to the owner. However, no rule is without exception – and the Supreme Court has derived such an exception for the case of unlawful use of a piece of real property owned by a third party.

The amount of the compensatory payment to be made to the owner for the use of their asset without any legal basis is based on the advantage gained by the unlawful user. In the case of real estate, established case law says the ill-gotten advantage can be expressed in money by taking one's cue from the amount of the customary rent in the market at the given place and time for a comparable property, which a tenant would under normal circumstances be compelled to pay. In this sense, the compensation to be paid is being derived from the level of market rent, though attention must always be given to the specific circumstances and conditions of the actual piece of real estate.

In actual practice, it is not always possible to determine what amount of rent is market standard, e.g. because "comparable properties" are in fact not fit to be let and thus not marketable. This concerns in particular neglected properties in a poor structural condition.

In such cases, the Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that those who used such third-party property without any legal title did not gain any pecuniary advantage to the detriment of the owner, and that they therefore did not have to pay any monetary compensation to the owner.

Clearly, this solution is relevant only in highly specific cases. Even so, one may question the Supreme Court's wisdom, as it is doubtful whether this solution is equitable and fair.

Source:
Judgment 28 Cdo 4184/2018 by the Czech Supreme Court of 27 February 2019

 

 

  • КАНТОРИТЕ НА BNT
  • Кооперационен партньор
КАНТОРИТЕ НА BNT

Свързани със света, силни в региона

Разполагаме с десет кантори и с международен екип от специалисти, които от години работят съвместно в сърцето на Европа. Канторите ни са разположени в метрополисите на региона, ръководят се от съдружниците децентрализирано и си сътрудничат.

Още
  • Минск
  • Sofia
  • Прага
  • Талин
  • Нюрнберг
  • Будапеща
  • Рига
  • Вилнюс
  • Варшава
  • Братислава
  • Букурещ
  • Тимишоара
bnt attorneys at law - Zuzana Chudáčková

Just like the legal systems, mentalities always differ from country to country. That is why our law offices are always right there on location.

Zuzana Chudáčková
Partner / Slovakia

bnt attorneys at law - Tomáš Běhounek

Our clients want to get ahead. That's why we get straight to the point and give them precise legal advice with clear recommendations.

Tomáš Běhounek
Partner / Czech Republic

bnt attorneys at law - Martin Neupert

Being directly involved in my clients' legal affairs excites me. That way I can really get to the heart of the matter.

Martin Neupert
Partner / Germany, Poland and Bulgaria

bnt attorneys at law - Rainer Tom

In a foreign language the nuances are important. As a native speaker you understand more precisely what is really being said and can give accurate legal advice.

Rainer Tom
Partner / Hungary